19 Cookout Secret Menu Items Worth Trying In 2024

Have you ever wondered what if your favorite restaurant is hiding a secret from you? Cookout, the king of southern cuisine, makes sure its luscious menu doesn’t go stale as it keeps a secret vault of dishes that the customers never taste. Let’s check out the 19 Cookout secret menu items you must try in 2024 to unmask the flavorful secret our favorite restaurant’s been hiding for all these years!

What’s on the Cookout Secret Menu?

All flavor adventurers and Cookout lovers assemble! The Cookout secret menu is a hidden section that includes secret main dishes, sides, shakes, and drinks. As the name suggests, these items have never been put on the regular menu.

The restaurant has kept them a secret only for the fans who stick by the company through thick and thin. It is time to reward our passion for southern-style BBQ by exploring the hidden gems on the menu.

Cookout Secret Menu Items You Must Try

The Cookout secret menu is divided into five sections. You can get special main dishes, sides, and special sauces alongside some secret shakes in the creamery section. Let’s check out all the dishes available on the menu:

Hidden Main Entrees at Cookout

Everything Burger

This hidden burger lives up to the hype. Ask the staff to order the big double burger with your favorite side. Instruct them to stuff the burger with all Cookout burger toppings, including pickles, lettuce, tomatoes, chili, and onion rings.

Firecracker Hot Dog

This one’s only for those who can bear some heat. Order a regular hot dog and add chili, onions, ketchup, mustard, and loads of cajun seasoning to turn up the spice level.

Peanut Butter Paradise Burger

Now, hear me out; it’s as delicious as it sounds weird. Order a regular burger and request the staff to put peanut butter on the beef patty. Now, top it off with some crispy bacon to call it a day!

BBQ Tray with Sandwich Slaw

Order the Cookout BBQ tray and ask the staff to add coleslaw, Cookout fries, and hushpuppies as your side. The staff would give you a full plate instead of a tray so that you can enjoy a larger portion of the BBQ at the same price.

Texas Pete with Chicken Quesadilla

Beware, this secret item is only for those who can handle some extreme heat. Request the staff for a chicken quesadilla to be drizzled with the Texas Pete hot sauce along with some melted cheddar cheese. A sweet milkshake is a must to handle this heat!

Tacos

These Mexican delights are currently available in select locations. You can ask the staff if they’ve got the ingredients to order this one.

Mexi Dog

These Mexican delights are currently available in select locations. You can ask the staff if they’ve got the ingredients to order this one.

Check also: Cookout Tray Menu.

Cookout Secret Sides

The hidden umami isn’t limited to the main entrees. Here are all the sides you can get on the Cookout secret menu:

Grilled Cheese

Fried Okra

Try this popular Southern dish that’s made with sliced okra deep-fried in seasoned batter. You can get it as a side with any other meal.

Hushpuppies

This dish is a traditional Southern-style side with a flavor to die for! You can order these deep-fried fritters made with cornmeal alongside any main dish as a substitute for fries.

Bacon and Grilled Onion Fries

Now, this dish combination transforms your fries into a crispy delight. Ask the staff to put bacon and grilled onions on your Cookout fries to turn them into an umami-packed side.

Cookout Secret Milkshakes

Cookies and Cream Freakshake

This rich, creamy milkshake can be ordered by asking for a vanilla milkshake. Instruct the staff to add crushed Oreos along with some whipped cream. Sprinkle some cookie dough in it, and you’re done with a rich shake with a long-lasting flavor.

Chocolate Banana Pudding Shake

It’s another creamery delight that takes the honey-like sweetness up a notch. You can order it by asking for a regular Banana Pudding shake and requesting a chocolate base.

Nilla Wafers in Shakes

Ask the staff to put a cobbler in any shake to get a Nilla wafer-infused milkshake.

Pumpkin Pie Shake

It’s made with a rich pumpkin pie that’s added to your regular shake to give an irresistible flavor.

Peanut Butter & M&M Shake

Although this shake is available in most locations, it’s still a mystery for certain stores in the country. Just ask the staff to make a vanilla shake and add M&Ms and peanut butter into it.

Secret Desserts at Cookout

Walnut Brownie

It’s a rich dessert with a dense, chocolaty flavor that’s taken to new heights with the added walnuts.

Cheesecake Extravaganza

Cookout serves the best cheesecakes in the country. You can order an extra cheesecake topping for a serving or put it in the milkshakes just for an additional $1.99.

Mix and Match to Create Your Secret Menu at Cookout

Cookout, being the best restaurant, allows you to customize your shake. You can create your own Cookout secret menu item, such as the Banana pudding shake with walnuts and chocolate chip that has a similar taste to banana bread.

Check also: Cookout Hours

Secret Side Combos at Cookout

The Cookout secret menu also serves side combinations like grilled cheese, fried okra, and bacon fries. Moreover, you can tweak your BBQ tray to get more slaw, fries, and hushpuppies. Also, you can combine these sides with a dish like Cookout Chicken Wrap to take your tastebuds to a flavorful ride.

Hidden Seasonal Specials at Cookout

Cookout offers secret seasonal specials that make fans go haywire. The Pumpkin Spice Shake, a Halloween delight, includes pumpkin pie added to the shake with nutmeg and cinnamon. Then there’s the Apple Pie Shake, a fall shake made with Apple pie, butter, and cinnamon. Lastly, there’s the Strawberry Shortcake Shake, that’s available during spring and made with strawberry shortcake added to a vanilla shake.

4 Tips to Order Your Secret Item at Cookout

Get Creative: Try out new topping combinations for your burgers and hot dogs. Also, you can experiment by mixing and matching various shake flavors, such as peanut butter and Heather’s or banana pudding and blueberry, to create your own Cookout secret menu dish.
The Tray is not the limit: Ask for additional sides like okra, cheesecake, and hushpuppies to make your BBQ tray a melting pot of flavors.
Be Polite: While customizing your meal is not a crime, make sure you keep things feasible and manageable for the hardworking staff. Be polite if they don’t have the ingredients and ask another day.

FAQs-Frequently Asked Questions

Although the restaurant hasn’t specifically stated, yes it serves an amazing secret menu for the loyal customers.

Yes, the secret items at Cookout are available at all locations. However, they may not be served sometimes due to a shortage of ingredients at certain stores.

The Cookout secret meals cost the same as the original menu items, but there can be additional charges for the extra toppings and mixtures.

Yes, you can mix your Cookout secret dishes to your liking.

Some secret items, like the seasonal shakes, are available for a limited time. In contrast, the rest of the meals are available throughout the year.

Conclusion

The Cookout secret menu unveils a whole new world of flavor combinations that’ll surely take your taste buds to a flavorful adventure. However, it would help if you remembered that these items may not be available at all stores. Feel free to ask the staff, and who knows, you might discover something even we don’t know!

19 Cookout Secret Menu Items You Should Definitely Try In 2024

What’s on the Cookout Secret Menu?